Peter Pan Diner

999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore, NY 11706 Order now
Hero image

Specializing in Sandwiches, Salads and More!

quotation

Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Peter Pan Diner Reviews on Grubhub

Jenifer

Top Reviewer
Ordered three different wraps to share. They were all delicious especially the Thanksgiving turkey type one ! I still can't figure out how the French fries come hot but not soggy when they deliver but they do . The complimentary rice pudding is always a hit w my husband . You can tell they take , prepare and deliver your order w care. I have ordered at least 15 times in the past year or so . I only had a problem once and they "over corrected " it to the point where I almost felt bad . The Grub Hub web site makes it so easy to order and pay . Don't be alarmed by the wait for the delivery , they are always twenty minutes early !

Donald

1 review
First time we used GrubHub although we've gotten a lot of food from Peter Pan over the last 13 years. Their phone lines were extremely busy so my wife suggested we use GrubHub and it worked very well. The food was excellent as always (love their specialty burgers) and it was ready right on time. Very satisfied all around.

rebecca

4 reviews
The food was excellent and everything was warm when they came to my door. The driver was friendly and even came earlier. Sometimes the food is a hit or miss with Peter Pan maybe it's different chefs who makes the orders but this time I was impressed. I got the chicken quesadilla seafood bisque and surf and turf

Gary

3 reviews
the food was great as always. my husband gets the gobble gobble wrap and says its the breatest wrap in the world. so it a must have. they came much earlier than the 45-55 min the app said. It was about 20minutes tops. we have been going to this diner since i was in diapers and its still a great place.

Tina

1 review
Has to be the best delivery service I've ever experienced.. They even sent a complimentary dessert. Not crazy about the $20 minimum, but definitely worth every cent.. I will continue to order from them, time n time again...if I could, I'd give them 100 stars. Well done Peter Pan Diner.

Reviews from Seamless.com

Peter Pan Diner Reviews on Seamless

David

2 reviews
The food was amazing! And the delivery guy was very nice and well prepared with my changed as I paid with cash. He has the exact change I needed back ready before he even arrived! Overall great restaurant, I will definitely be choosing the Peter Pan Diner again on Seamless!!

Jessica

Top Reviewer
Very good food. I was happy to see they delivered to Brentwood. I ordered for 7 people which came out to be a large order. It was delivered promptly and they even gave us free rice pudding.

Joseph

4 reviews
Excellent food and fast delivery! Every once and a while they throw in a free rice pudding too. You can't go wrong ordering from Peter Pan!

Megan

1 review
Delivery was very quick! They came sooner than the expected time. We enjoyed ordering from Peter Pan Diner.

Jessica

Top Reviewer
Super delicious! Delivery was fast, order was correct and hot! Always satisfied.

About us

BBQ, Breakfast, Dinner, Hamburgers, Lunch Specials, Salads, Wraps
Today
Delivery: 8:00 AM - 9:45 PM
Takeout: 8:00 AM - 9:45 PM

Most of you know us very well. After all, we've been a landmark in the Long Island community for over 4 years. Fact is, anywhere you go from New York to California and clear across the globe, if you mention Long Island, you'll hear the words " Do you know the Peter Pan Diner? " Owners, Gus, Nick And Peter Are familiar faces you've come to know and love over the years, always ready with a smile, a handshake and of course.. A menu! That's What The Peter Pan Diner is all about, after all. Good food, good people and good memories. We often see the same faces every single day. We serve up the best value for your dollar all day, every day! So Come and join our Peter Pan Family. No matter what the occasion, we'll be there for you. From a little league post-game snack to Sunday brunch, this is the place to meet old friends or make new ones.